We shouldn’t waste the time before the budget wars begin again
Larry Persily, Published October 21, 2019, Anchorage Daily News
chances of a special legislative session this fall diminish, Alaskans have some extra time to think about
how to fix the state’s fiscal future next year.
Legislature will convene in regular session in less than 90 days and no doubt
the budget, public services and long-term finances will dominate the debates —
as they should. We’ve confronted — and at the same time avoided — the problems
since the 1990s. The indecision is hurting our communities and Alaska’s
off the decisions in election years for fear of punishment at the polls, and
have been unable to solve them in non-election years because too many players
are looking ahead to the next campaign.
while, the big-number options for balancing spending and revenues are unchanged
despite years of arguing, spreadsheets and town halls: Cut state spending on
public services; collect taxes from individual Alaskans, non-resident workers
and/or visitors; increase taxes on oil production; use Permanent Fund earnings
and adjust the calculation for the annual Permanent Fund dividend.
talk all they want about railroads to Canada, roads to remote Alaska mining districts, mythical North Slope natural gas pipelines and hypothetical benefits of being “open for business” (whatever that overused slogan means), but the mathematical
reality is that none of the above politically inflated legends could ever
produce enough state revenue to avoid the hard decisions on public services,
taxes and the size of the PFD.
decisions should be based on reality, not dreams.
decisions on public services, taxes and the PFD are uncomfortable, even painful
to many, and all are politically dangerous, maybe even politically deadly. But
waiting any longer isn’t going to make some new option appear out of nowhere or
make the problems go away, just like the broccoli isn’t going to disappear from
the 12-year-old’s plate no matter how long he avoids it.
is all of the above (minus the broccoli). Everyone benefits in the long term if
everyone contributes. The odds of political success are better if everyone
In the 1969
film, “Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid,” Robert Redford and Paul Newman
survived when they jumped off the cliff together. Sure, they were being chased
by a posse for robbing a train — unlike Alaska, which is being chased by fiscal
reality — but the solution is the same: Take the leap together.
legislators and the governor — and the public — need to work next year toward a
comprehensive plan for a healthy, stable long-term fiscal future for Alaska.
permanently restructuring the dividend formula to an affordable level that can
pay Alaskans for decades.
spending enough on public services to protect and educate Alaskans, while
building for the future, but resisting spending on programs and special
projects that are beyond the role of government.
looking at a broad-based tax on individuals, so that all Alaskans, and the
guests who enjoy and prosper during their time in the state, contribute.
And it means
the oil industry should not be excused from the collective answer.
mean expecting the oil industry to solve all our problems with one big check, like
the backers of the oil tax initiative promote. The industry knows it will
always be a deep pocket in Alaska. What worries the decision-makers in
corporate offices is the 40-year history that they are the only pocket we reach
into. That attitude among many Alaskans, and the resulting fear among the
industry, is destructive of future investment.
hope is that the higher-oil-taxes-solve-everything lobby, the
don’t-touch-my-PFD lobby, the no-new-taxes lobby, and the cut-spending lobby
will put down their signs, stifle their campaign rhetoric, stop their Facebook
attacks and find an all-of-the-above compromise.
Larry Persily is a
longtime Alaska journalist, with breaks for federal, state and municipal jobs
in oil and gas and taxes, including deputy commissioner at the Alaska
Department of Revenue 1999-2003. He is teaching journalism this fall at the
University of Alaska Anchorage.